What Makes a Good Mother
79Are children reflections of us...or themselves?
Child A gets into Harvard and goes on to become a famous brain surgeon. Child B drops out of high school, takes a dead-end job, and spends his days getting high.
How much, if any, of the credit/blame for these choices should each boy's mother take? What if the boys are brothers? Is the mom a good mom... or a bad mom?
Let's face it. Parenting is are hard job. It's the hardest job in the world. And like it or not, mothers are held to a higher standard of responsibility than fathers. Don't mean to sound sexist here. You can dispute it if you want. I'm simply speaking from my own experience.
That experience has recently got me thinking. I've met plenty of attentive mothers who dote on their kids. I've also met my share of mothers whose children have been taken away by CPS (Child Protective Services). In between is a broad spectrum of parenting styles and experiences.
I wrote this in poem to share mine with you.
I’m the kind of mother
who looks like the others
acts like the others
seems pretty normal
I do Mom things like them
work in the classroom
put on my game face
cheer on the sidelines
Other moms stress over
test scores and game scores
will Johnny get in?
are his grades good enough?
Judging from the outside
they’d never, ever guess
how different I am
how healed yet damaged
When it comes to my child
my worries are basic
more crises, really
is he still alive?
Life jags sideways then down
the signposts familiar
I know what to do
maternal instinct
Myself a survivor
No stranger to darkness
to numbing out pain
as my mother did
Today I’m a mother
who does interventions
who interviews rehabs
prays for redemption
Thank God I’m a mother
whose child has been to Hell
together we’ve clawed
our way back to hope
Good-bye, Mom
That’s what I can offer
the friend who saved her son
thwarting suicide
with psych ward lockdown
That’s tough to explain
to those other mothers
sheltered as they are
not in their worldview
They’d be shocked to know
I'm the kind of mother
Whose parenting skills
Are sharpened by instinct
Am I a “good” mother?
what is good anyway?
the absence of malice
abundance of love
©Mighty Mom 2009. All rights reserved.
Some Resources
- Parenting Teens - Troubled Teen Help Information.
Information for parents of teens, including troubled teens, parenting tips, teen education, and more. - Teen Drug Abuse Home Page - Teen Drug Abuse and Addiction - Find Help for Teen Drug Abuse
Find teen drug rehabs and alcoholism treatment centers listed here in an easy to use searchable directory. Also, information and resources for parents. - Teen Drug Addiction Rehab Teen Drug Rehabilitation Drug Addiction Teen Treatment Centers
Find drug rehab and drug rehabilitation treatment centers listed here in an easy to use searchable directory. All of the nations best drug treatment centers and rehabs are listed. - The Prevention Researcher
- Teen Suicide - Adolescent Suicide Statistics and Prevention
Teen suicide statistics and articles on adolescent suicide prevention as well as teenage suicide warning signs. Get the stats on teen suicide today and related issues like teen depression.
![]() | Amazon Price: $7.54 List Price: $16.95 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $14.99 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $1.99 |
Amazon Price: $7.48 List Price: $15.99 |
CommentsLoading...
Here are my thoughts; you inspire the values of love, understanding, responsibility forgiveness, and kindness by example. You love them unconditionally and show support while they strive to achieve “their” dreams. Need I say you also pray a lot. {•.•}
I do not know if I am a good mother or not. I am just a mother.
Yes, of course, I would love for my son to go to Harvard or Princeton or Yale but I have decided early on that whatever will make him happy is what is good for him so from the time he was 12 years old he became "independent" of me with respect to clothes and food.
I taught him how to cook at 12 and while we went to the Mall together, I let him choose and pay for his choices while I waited in the lobby of our Mall.
I only had to keep reminding him of two things: "To whom much is given, much is also required"..this is a Bible quote and "With great privilege come great responsibility"
I think he is pretty happy most of the time and I am sure that his choices in life will be sound, whatever they maybe.
You are a wonderful mom, You are even more experienced than the moms who go around with blinders on their entire life. So what the kid (A) gets into Harvard, maybe at the frat parties he does things that the Stoner (B) would never do! Just because one child is more successful in life doesn't make them any better than the other. Its their hearts that make the difference. And us as mothers that is our jobs to give them love, and teach them. Sometimes kids fall down in life and make mistakes or have problems, mothers shouldn't be to blame. As adults or young adults they may not have thought things through as us parents would have. Again, mother's shouldn't be blamed. I think you are a wonderful mom and you just keep being the great person you are, things will always work out in the end. I am living proof of that. My mom taught me well, I didn't get an Ivy League education but I got schooled in the Hard Knock life and common sense she instilled in me and although I made some serious mistakes and poor choices I would never say she is to blame. On the contrary, I think the seeds she planted in my heart and mind helped me straighten up in the end and change my life......Kudos to your hub! =)
Awesome hub!
PS Sometimes they have to screw up before they buckle down and fly right....
Well I surely ain't no Mom but what would we do without them? At a young ripe age we felt the comfort and security that we will never feel again in life. As we head into our teens, we won't remember this and they are just in our way but they are good enough to get us what we want. We can manipulate them, or so we think. We finally grow up and start our own life rarely looking back. Finally we settle down and we wish we had the security, comfort and unconditional love they gave us as kids. Mom is now wise, we love her dearly and what would I have been without her loving care. Finally, we have kids and we start the process all over, but this time, we say "What would Mom have done?"
I think we just do the best we can. I have 3 sons and they all turned out just fine although I had my doubts about the youngest one for a while. As I see it, our jobs as parents are to teach our children to stand on their own two feet. Too many give in to their child's every whim and pay their way out of jams. That never promotes maturity.
I agree...parenting,and especially a mother's role, must be the most difficult thing in the world. How do you know you're getting it right?
You are without a doubt a 'good mother' a GREAT MOTHER in fact. It shows through your pain in your writing. You had me in tears out of sympaty and empathy for your plight. Please know you are not alone in this plight even though it feels like it. Write me anytime.
Okay. You included a solo piece by ex-Beatle, the late John Lennon. ya gotta love how he turned something negative into something that made him lots of money. I had to post a comment if only to compliment you on that smart move, MM. (I referenced you again on my Halloween hub by the way.)
It's pretty much complicated for me as a man, but I'm sure that maternity is a full time job no doubt. It's not only the mother who raises her kids or instills good morals into them, it's also the society around them and school, friends...etc SO, the mother is only a part of this process and she should get involved in all her kids activities to ensure they're on the right path.
Such an insightful and revealing hub. Having two daughters who mirror the descriptions in your writing and connecting to the myriad of feelings a mother has who has gone through the similar ups and downs that go with them...and the soul searching, I can totally relate. Thanks for laying it all out....a painful catharsis, I'm sure.
Great Hubs!! Glad I've found you here...
Hey Mighty Mom! As a mom myself, I can understand where you are coming from. We often wish our kids came with instruction manuals so that we could figure the complicated parts out. Love and nurturing sometimes does not seem to be enough these days. I find that if make time my kids make time. It does hold true that family involvement, I don't mean the sneaking in their room and reading their diary kind of involvement, makes a huge difference. We have family night and either watch a movie, play a game or just act silly. I expect my children to do their best and remind them the grade does not make them who they are but the spirit they carry in them and how they react to situations. I tell them to listen to their gut. Moms words start ringing in their heads at some point and they realize that you weren't talking to hear yourself talk~
Parenting is a rough life for any one, no matter who they are. One does the best one can and hopes all will work out, love is given with tentative care to the one who needs it at the time. Some lose their way and we strive to help them back, we can't always win. Lucky for you and yours you have pulled one from hell and that is a wonderful win. Good luck MM and thanks for sharing a powerful story. CC
I don't think parents have as much control as they think they do. My experience has been that kids will do what they shouldn't because they are kids, but in the end they will do what you do, not what you say. Have my kids done some crazy dangerous stuff I wish they hadn't? Yes. Have they picked up some of my worst habits? Yes. Are they nevertheless separate individual people with their own lives and their own minds? Yes..
It's the last thing people tend to forget. People treat their kids like accessories or achievements (or failures) but they're PEOPLE. I also am distressed by how much we judge other women by their parenting skills or lack thereof, even though people with awful parents often grow up to be wonderful people and people with wonderful parents often grow up to be jerks. So it's obviously NOT all about us and our parenting skills.
Great hub. Your caring comes through in every word.
I don't think you could've said it better than you did, MM. I don't have kids of my own (that I know of) but hope to one day father several kids if possible and to raise them as I see fit. One of the best jobs I ever had was as a camp counselor in New Hampshire. I had the privilege to be one for a total of 3 summers and I enjoyed every minute of it as it was a truly rewarding experience incomparable to other jobs I've ever held. I feel that I just "get it" when it comes to kids.
There is a reason why Mother's Day is the biggest day for restaurants. Father's Day doesn't even come close. Shame on the families that make mom cook (or do anything for that matter) on her birthday OR Mother's Day. In Asian culture, we respect are elders and especially our parents and do everything to honor them. When my parents' marriage was falling apart, my dad asked me if I would go and live with him and I told him rather than my mom: "Don't ask me that question, dad!"
Thanks, MM for a wonderful hub and inspiring poem.
My mother was one of the best moms ever walked the earth. When she died, a part of me went with her. It had been ten years on March 7, 2009, but I cry even to this day. I was the last of four kids she salvaged from eleven efforts, and so it affected me more than the others. The thing I remember most about her was that she never compromised the truth. As long as I was wrong, I was going to get it. I didn't understand why she came down so hard on me, but realizing what the world is today, I am glad she did. She could have been selfishly suppressing the right thing just to gain my affection, but she stuck to what she suspected would have been advantageous to help me face the challenges in later years. In other words, it wasn't about her, but about after she was gone how I would be adaptable to a cruel world. Hence, to test your maternal skills, my suggestion is to put your kid(s) in the framework of living independently, to see if he could survive without you. If he can't, then you might have work to do. The responsibility of you as a parent is to pass on survival kits so that when you leave this earth, your soul can rest in peace.
I think a good mother is one who loves her children, but not unconditionally. Using the example you gave, I wouldn't blame the mother at all. Free will is the real culprit. You could do everything in the world for a person, but its up to them to either accept or reject your help.
Awsome hub Mighty Mom,
I can only speak as a father of 3 daughters. I teach them only that everything they do has a consiquence, it ripples out and affects others, good or bad, so be responsible because ripples that touch return. They can talk to me about anything and I only offer my opinion and not a lecture.
I show them how to be sociable and understanding that others see through different eyes so don't judge. We can choose to live as a victim of circumstance or apreciate the positive and find our own way. Never follow others into the fire to gain acceptance, true friends will love you for who you are.
Find your creative side and express yourself that way.
Can a mother be blamed? A child learns with it's eyes, but it owns it's own head. Strong or weak, it's not your fault.
A mother's role in a child's development had been a subject to a lot of studies. Long ago,I even came across a theory that points out to the nature of a child's relationship with the mother throughout the young formative years, as a possible contributory factor in developing a schizophrenic disorder-- bold and outrageoue it might be, what it only tries to tell is the undeniable role of a mother to a child's personality development. Being the ever present and primary figure that fills in the care giver and nurturer role for a young mind that is impressionable and very vulnerable to what it is fed with and modeled with.
I can certainly see that you are doing what you think is best for your children, using your whole heart and soul, with all the wisdom you can ever make great use of.
For us mothers, at the end of the day, that is all that actually really matter. Knowing in our hearts that we have given them a piece of our very being with all the power and might we could gather, just so we could give them our unconditional love. Continue being there for your children, as a daughter myself, I can say that a mother's mere presence, moreso her love and prayers, are the deep sources of strength and courage for a son or a daughter.
May God bless all mothers, with more courage and strength to give the same to their children, and for their children to give to their own children!
My mom was simply the best! My father was good too, but nothing compared to Mom. I was lucky to have them both at home. However, it's like we were always at the forefront of Mom's mind. As soon as she got paid, she came straight home to us. My father had to stop at the bar first, and by the time he reached us, we were well looked after already. Nothing beats a good mother.
Ok how weird is it that we both did Hubs on mom's the same day? Mine of course, sad and tragic, bringing me down, but now I feel good having read yours, as I often do. So glad to see your poetry as well again. I feel an interview coming on.hhhmmmmm.............xo
Nicely written. I agree with you about Mothers being held up to a higher standard, it is sexist too but you're not being sexist you're just observing the sexist reality! I'm afraid sometimes the higher standard puts a lot of pressure on Moms and it stresses them out to the point that they can alienate their own kids. Thanks for the great article, it's made me think more about my own Mom and her personal struggles. I just finished a parenting hub too that I'm pretty proud of, if you get the chance check it out! Thanks Mighty Mom!
MM, I liked this hub.. the mother sets the tone for the whole family, don't we
glad to know that you are mighty...
Great hub , mom's are people too , I think that is important thing to instill in our children. We are all doing the best we can with what we have at the time.
Mighty mom this is such a great hub, poem is outstanding...thanks!!
Nice to read, as a mum of 2 - boy & girl I sometimes struggle with their wills but they have to be allowed to be individual, although draw the line at drawing pictures on the walls od the rented house!!
Also having suffered from PND that only my husband knew about you wonder how all these other "normal" mothers cope,or what problems they have?
you have a good hubs, i really appreciate your work . keep it up.
I am not still A mother but in God's will I will be soon..being a mother is not an easy task we can quit if we don't want.If you commit it then it is forever, a commitment that you can't brake.I love my mom and I adore all mother.:)
Mighty Mom, This was wonderful!
Being a Mom is one of the most difficult, loving, overwhelming, painful, wisdom building, artistic, joyful, multi tasked and often fulfilling roles there is. I believe it is a combination of every important career one will every obtain!
Kudos for you! Again wonderful! Blessings!
One of the greatest mysteries of parenting is how two children raised in the same family can experience two totally different lives. We must always remember that each child is his own person, his own spirit, so taking credit or blame for their outcomes becomes a very interesting concept. We can guide them the best we can but ultimately they must make some very important decisions for themselves.
great hub! I kept having doubts about my parenting abilities, after going through a harrowing time in the past two years. Now I discovered that I'm not alone.
Take a break and enjoy some crimson and clover MOM. :D 'twill make ya feel good.
nighty, nite
As a mom of a teenager off to college, expereincing the empty nest-I now have plenty of time on my hands to wonder... should I have? Could I have? Its strangely comforting to know that most moms question. I Thank God we can rest assured knowing beyond our questions, He loves our kids more than we could ever and has great plans for them.
You are a mighty mom huh?
So, he is ok? well, alive?
Are you Ok?
Bad Mothers do exist. I promise.Your NOT one... But even the bad mothers, in some odd twisted way, do love thier children the best they can. I try every day, to be better then my mother was. Sometimes its hard, she didn't give me the tools, the rules, or anything to go by. I have to figure it out as I go. So, sometimes I have to say sorry. Yes, part of who you are is due to how you were riased, but at some point, a child grows up and must be responsable for their actions. That part is all on their own. I chose to udnerstand and forgive my mother, as best I could, and move on. If people were completly who their parents were or raised them to be...what a boring world this would be...
What a great hub, Mighty Mom. I give my mom all the credit in the world, she had five of us and while we're not all doing what we thought we would, we're all happy and whole. Thanks!
MightyMom, I think from reading your hub, you are a great mother! thanks for sharing.
Robert Ballard
The path of a Mom is always riddled with self doubt. No matter how good our intentions are we are always presented with a different scenario that throws those questions in front of us. You know you did the best you were able to do and still the what-ifs show-up in a low or weak moment. Stick to your guns because you know you're a good Mom.
great hub, once again one that is close to my heart.
kindest regards Zsuzsy
I think all most of us can do is to do our best and then hope....and then accept. I like how your poem ended: 'the absence of malice/ abundance of love' - I guess that sums it up so well.
You're more than a Mighty Mom - you're a Great Mom :)
We all wonder if we did a good job as a mom. We can only do what we know how to do. We cannot fix our children, only hope that we have instilled in them, enough of what they need to grow and be happy.
If being a good mom means loving your child as yourself-I made the grade. If being a good mom means your child turns out wonderful, I am lacking...but I take comfort in the fact that God is the perfect Father and look at all his children!
MightyMom this was a very POWERFUL hub and many moyjers do need to read this I loved it and felt your heart bleeding through it as I read it!!
Two of my four children graduated from top universities, USC and U of M, my youngest is attending U of M. My oldest son graduated from high school with my foot in his back. I worried my self sick about him. Then my dad asked me these question. Is he respectful to you?---Yes
Do the police come knocking at your door?---No
Is he a hard worker?----Yes where ever he works
people like him.
My Dad said then what are you worried about. And do you know he has turned out just fine. There were some rough years but he is now living in LA, has been voted employee of the year where he works and is HAPPY.
I believe that children are their own people. You can give them rules and guidance and pick them up when they fall but in the end, they responsible for the choices they make.
been where you've been and walked in the metaphor "clawed the way back to hope" - exquisite
Mighty Mom,
Thanks for sharing your heart. I know what it is to walk in the world of motherhood that others take for granted as a mom of child with special needs. Two of the most powerful words in the english language are "Me Too."
I am the mom of two boys, one with special needs and one who should have them. The one I birthed is laden with special needs, the one I adopted from a drug mom is Harvard bound, if he wants. I love them both so very much and wish so much so for them. It hurts and I am blessed. Dealing in difficult.
Being a might mom is not my forte but I try.
My wife is a mother every minute of every day, even though our four "kids" are between 28 and 35. She loves them all in a way I can never get close to. The odd call or skype to them does me fine, but she actually communicates with them and knows what is concerning them and then does something positive about it. I don't want the world to be filled with only mums(we don't say "Mom" in the UK), but I know it would be a better place if it was. Keep up the great work, Mighty Mon.
I ran into a mother at church the other day. She was in tears since her 20 year-old daughter won't speak to her because she and her husband decided to adopt two darling little boys. She asked me why her daughter was doing this, and wondered if she was a good mother for adopting other children. She lavished love and attention on this young woman her whole life; did she "spoil" her? I don't think so. My sister-in-law is a caring, loving woman, raised as an only child since her siblings were grown when she was born. She too was doted on, yet turned out very different. I think that everything we do and are as parents will affect our children, but each child is individual as well and has other influences beside us. I think that if we love truly, then we are good mothers. We each do our best, and you cannot get better than that.
Hi Mighty Mom. I'm not yet a mom but experiencing how it is to raise my 3-year old niece has really made me question if I'll ever become ready to become one. Hope when the time comes, my answer will be yes, I'm a good (not great) mother :). Thanks for the hub.
Hello Mighty Mom,
As a Son I can tell you that we do learn from example, the only problem is, outside influences also play a major roll in this process. Can I be honest here? The major problem we face in the family today is due to the Lazy Fathers who did not and do not stand up to their role. When I look back over the last couple of decades I see a miserable failure of Fathers, untold numbers forsook their Wives, forsook the Children, and ran from responsibility. Because of this the Children ran wild and began to associate with outside influences that led to what we have today in America.
I'll tell you, most Moms have done their job well, they have loved their Children to the point of exhaustion. They have done all they can do to give them the tools to choose the right path. I have watched over the years as many of these Moms children who had taken the wrong path, have eventually turned around. So I never look at any case and declare it as a lost case.
thank you for this my mother was the one who is a good mother but my dad is another story
I came late to this hub, but here's my two bits worth:
A good mother is one who doesn't eat her young.
End of story.
That was good to read. Made me think of my mom and all she's done for me. I think a good mom is the one that's their for her children. We didn't have a lot of money growing up so we didn't have many things, but my mom always made sure we had fun. It wasn't till I was older that I actually realized all she had done. Good Hub
A good mother probably is one you don't fail to remember even if she has died. You just can't simply let her memories of your good old days vanish with her mortal body. You enjoy her immortal presence by several links like, remembering her on her birthday, wedding day, death anniversary, etc. Mine is a good if not the best mother. I love to write articles about her and for her in loving memory of her being my mom.Nice hub!
The 'nurture or nature' question is always an intriguing one. I like the way you posed the question about these two different children. The latest research seems be pointing more towards nature than was previously believed. Great hub!
I learned how to be a great father from my wonderful mother!
Your definition of 'good' is perfect: "the absence of malice, abundance of love". In hoping to be 'good' moms, we have no intentions of ill-will for our children and we have all the hope in the world that their lives will be as stable as possible, even if we can't guarantee that stability.
Beautiful poem! Thanks for sharing your insights.
I think you are completely right the most we can do as mothers is try our hardest to guide our children through life to the best of our ability, and let them be individuals at the same time. Your hub has inspired me in many ways as I am a new mom too a 4 month old daughter and feel sometimes as if I am not a great mother but I give my daughter as much love as I possibly can and try my hardest to make sure that she has everything she needs. Granted she's not that old yet but she sure is getting good at grabbing things on her own and trying to stick them in her mouth, so for now I am just trying to keep her out of harms way. (and by harms way I mean chocking on something she try's to but in her mouth), So I want to thank you and everyone else who has commented for the inspirational words for the years to come with my daughter.


























































GusTheRedneck Level 6 Commenter 2 years ago
Hi MightyMom - Well, I am certainly not a mother, but I undersatnd what you are saying. Gus